RoboColosseum evaluates general robotic strategies across different robots and environments, finding weak consistency across robot platforms, limited open-world reliability, and significant differences in zero-shot and fine-tuning performance. This distributed evaluation framework assessed five visual language action (VLA) strategies and three cutting-edge AI agents on four robot platforms (SO-101, Franka, dual-arm YAM, humanoid G1). The results show that cutting-edge agents are comparable to dedicated VLA strategies, but all systems perform poorly in open-world tasks. RoboColosseum evaluates physical intelligence in large-scale real environments.