'Defense by ChatGPT'
'Defense by ChatGPT'
US Department of Justice lawyers used AI writing detection service Pangram to accuse opposing lawyers of using ChatGPT for defense, and claimed in court documents that the opposing party submitted 'AI dirty work' applications, centered around a new news scandal case. Recent Justice Department documents show that lawyers are mutually accusing each other of using AI, and using the other party's AI usage as court arguments. Government lawyers stated in the case file: 'This case has become a ChatGPT defense.'

We've written a lot about how AI generated writing has collided with – and created chaos for – the legal system in the last few years, from lawyers using it to do their research and filings for them to judges getting extremely fed up with dealing with these attorneys. In some cases, judges have sanctioned offending attorneys thousands of dollars for using AI to do their jobs, and lawyers give endless excuses when they're busted, with some calling it a “cautionary tale." Today's story is about how the DOJ is getting involved: by trying to catch attorneys doing "defense by ChatGPT."
The Department of Justice Is Using AI Detector Pangram Against Defense Attorneys
Lawyers for the Department of Justice are using the AI writing detection service Pangram to argue that opposing attorneys are using AI to write legal arguments, and in one case told the court that opposing counsel was doing “defense by ChatGPT,” and writing “AI slop” filings, according to court filings reviewed by 404 Media.
Over the last few years, we have documented many attorneys getting caught by judges using AI after citing hallucinated cases that do not exist. The filings in this court case over the past month show attorneys, including those working for the government, are trying to catch each other using AI, then are citing their opponents’ AI use in their arguments to the court.
“This case has turned into defense by ChatGPT,” government attorneys wrote in the case, which centers around a high-profile voter fraud case. “Motions practice in this case is the equivalent of writing responses to documents generated by a robot that is attempting to practice law. It cannot be that the local rules envisioned that it was acceptable for defense to use what the kids would call ‘AI slop’ to create multiple frivolous motions that waste judicial resources and fail to serve the cause of justice.”
Read the rest of this story here.
MORE FROM 404
404 contributor Matthew Gault took the bullet for us all: “Three hours and 15 minutes into the four hour long documentary Musk, a video game avatar of the titular billionaire picks up a chainsaw off the Resolute Desk in the Oval Office. Shot like a first-person shooter, the audience watches as Musk wields the chainsaw to destroy various government buildings. Walking through a farm, Musk aims the chainsaw at grain silos labeled ‘USDA’ and lightning arcs from its spinning blades. The silo explodes and cows moo in distress. In my experience, the purpose of a video game chainsaw is to viscerally rend through objects. I have never seen one shoot lightning. It’s a small detail that speaks to my overall problem with Alex Gibney’s Musk: it’s cringe.”
Source: 404 Media · 404media.co